This article was originally published in Statehouse News Bureau.
While other groups say they'll continue to fight, the executive director of the League of Women Voters says there isn't enough time in this year's election calendar to win.
Though the League of Women Voters of Ohio and the ACLU have been winning their redistricting cases before the Ohio Supreme Court, they say they’re having to pull back on their fight over the congressional map for this election because they’re out of time.
When the Ohio Supreme Court said it didn’t have jurisdiction over the second congressional map Republicans approved after the court ruled the first one unconstitutional, League of Women Voters executive director Jen Miller says her group’s case had to start all over.
Miller said the lack of time in this election calendar is one reason why her group filed suit to throw out that map in 2024 but not this year.
“It's painful to have one election cycle under this terrible congressional map. On the other hand, it would be far more painful if we ended up in federal court and for some reason, the map actually got worse, and our ability to secure fair maps in the future also became harder because of a precedent those court cases set," Miller said in an interview for "The State of Ohio". "And so it's confusing and it's hard to understand. What I can say is that we will continue to do everything we can for the people of Ohio."
Critics shared their anger over the decision on social media, saying the groups had given up and were settling for "rigged maps".
But Miller said while she understands the frustration, the anger is better directed at the Republicans who have controlled the redistricting process, which has been extended by months through delays and repeated court challenges.
"I do believe that the powers that be knew that time was on their side, that the closer that the primary came, the less likely we were to win in ending gerrymandering in Ohio," Miller said. "Even we had no idea that after we won time and time and time again in court that we would still see this play of running out the clock. But that's what they've done. And it's awful. It's gross, in my opinion, but it's where we're at."
Other groups say they will continue to fight the congressional map, which creates 10 Republican districts, three Democratic districts, and two competitive and slightly Democratic districts.
The A. Philip Randolph Institute said in a statement after the announcement from the League of Women Voters and the ACLU that was withdrawing from the lawsuit with the other groups, saying "the time for fair maps is now....the A. Philip Randolph Institute will always fight like hell for Ohioans' right to vote and for fair maps, and we cannot wait a minute longer. Justice delayed is justice denied.”
The Equal Districts Coalition, which includes Common Cause Ohio, the Ohio Environmental Council and the Ohio Organizing Collaborative - which filed one of the lawsuits over the legislative maps - plan an event Friday to explain their next steps.
The Latest from the League
The League of Women Voters of Ohio today announced participation in a lawsuit challenging the state's U.S. congressional districts as unconstitutional.
The League of Women Voters of Ohio filed an amicus brief in the case Ex Rel. Ohio Democratic Party v. Frank LaRose. The case concerns when and how to conduct Ohio’s rescheduled primary election in light of last week’s postponement due to COVID-19.